The following is a commentary abstracted from the documentary “The New York Doll”, directed by Greg Whiteley. The core source material for this essay is derived from that film, and any interpretations are the sole responsibility of the author. All readers are encouraged to source that material, and judge for themselves the messages contained.
Arthur Kane’s life was full of self deprecating tragedy and disappointment, until his later years which was full of faith and hope in a loving God and in what seemed to be a hopeless cause.
In his youth, he was a founding member of a rock band which is credited for pushing the limits of conventional music – The New York Dolls. Their dress, attitudes, and message was offensive to some, inspirational to other, and on all accounts ahead of their time by nearly a decade. After a few albums and a taste of success, Arthur found himself no longer with the band. Unable to remove himself from the lifestyle he had been accustom to, as well as the disappointment and jealously of other’s success in the absence of his own; his life became consumed with alcohol and drug abuse, violence, and a level of poverty from which he never fully recovered. His story was that of stereotyped rock stars.
His story also became that of stereotyped redemption.
In 1989 he met with missionaries from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and was baptized. His life changed as a result of the standards of the organization and the Gospel of Jesus Christ. He cleaned up his life, and eventually began to work in the Los Angeles temple genealogy library as a Missionary.
His new found life in Mormonism, didn’t diminish his love for music. Due to his current poverty his bass and guitars were often sitting in the pawn shop, protected in the back by his regular interest payments. He loved the Gospel, which renewed a love for his former band mates, and brought a degree of regret and remorse for the way things were left.
He understood the impact that their music had, and desired that after over 25 years he would somehow be able to play together again; that he would somehow correct the way things were left. Desire for the impossible increased. Although Arthur was content with his life, and the lot afforded to him, he often prayed, what some may consider irreverent but sincere prayers that he would again play with his band mates and that they would again get back together.
His prayers would seem counterintuitive to some; here is was a new man, clean, and worthy, praying for an opportunity to feel the joy of playing in his band again after two and half decades and to some degree re-entering the environment that was the genesis of all his sorrows and regrets.
Here was a man nearly 55 years of age, alone, in a small apartment in Los Angeles. He lives a quiet life, and commutes on the bus every morning to his Missionary responsibilities at the Genealogy center at the temple. His greatest joy, his strongest desire is that of reuniting with individuals whom he hasn’t spoken to in nearly 29 years, and going back to the mid-seventies when they were a band. This was his life, for what can be assumed nearly 15 years; relentless desire for the impossible.
Than in 2004 a call was received from a mutual friend in the music industry. He was hosting a rather famous festival in London and would like the New York Dolls to reunite; the rest of the band had already agreed, and all they were waiting for was Arthur. His prayers were answered – and his opportunity arrived.
He immediately accepted, and a new level of joy, excitement, and anxiety entered his life. With the help of some ward members, Arthur retrieved his pawned bass guitar and began practicing once again. He acknowledged his prayers were answered, but in a way absent of truly being surprised, more in the tone which acknowledged the answers of faith. He knew his fellow band members had not seen him since his conversion to the church, and was concerned about their impressions of him, and his new lifestyle. He was aware that things had changed over the years; and that more than likely his reunited colleagues would not follow the same principles.
Others close to Arthur were also concerned with his re-entry into the environments and stress which would be present; would he be able to survive spiritually in an environment which would be full of the vices which had consumed his life for so long?
The band reunion a few weeks previous to the big show took place, and the results were comforting to Arthur. The remaining members of the band welcomed him with open arms, as a new level of maturity was expressed among all of them. In preparation for the show the band practiced and rehearshed regularly – and new concerns were beginning to arise about Arthur’s ability to play. He hadn’t played on stage for decades, and was a little rough around the edges. Nevertheless the plans went forward, and the band arrived in London for the big show.
The message that the band was being reunited with Arthur brought fans out of the woodwork, and the audience was excited to see something that many of them had never been able to see before, and probably would never be able to see again.
To say that Arthur was a phenomenal missionary for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints through this process would be an overstatement; but to say that he was a remarkable example would be an understatement. Despite his environment of vices, and occasional jockeying from band mates in relation to his affiliation with the Mormons, he never appeared tempted, and was ever aware of who he now was. When jokes about the church were mentions he was always ready with a loving but accurately correcting comments in an attempt to educate those around him on the subject. When dressing for his performance on stage he used Joseph Smith has his projected image, wearing a white shirt with frills on the chest and a long door mans coat – presumably to simulate the artists renditions of Joseph from the 1840’s.
On stage that evening, despite concerns about his skills, Arthur and his band performed wonderfully. The fans were ecstatic, the fellow musicians of the festival were thrilled, and Arthur was on cloud nine. This was the greatest dream he could have ever wanted come true. There was even small talk about the band reunited for another album.
The festival eventually ended, and thrilled with the events Arthur returned to Los Angeles, woke up in his small apartment and boarded the bus for his responsibilities at the Los Angeles Temple Genealogy Library.
Twenty-two days after his return from London where the festival was held, and his triumphant return to the stage, Arthur complained of fatigue and was taken to the hospital. Two hours after his arrival, he was diagnosed with Leukemia, and passed away that evening.
There are a few assumptions from the life of Arthur that carry little doubt. Arthur was loved of the Lord, and he was blessed for his faithfulness. With that said, what was Arthur blessed with?
There is little doubt that the hand of the Lord was involved in, even what the music industry would consider, the miraculous reuniting of the New York Dolls after nearly three decades. There is little doubt that the Lord was involved in the timing of that event; the Lord knew the days of Arthur were numbered and what would bring him the greatest joy in this life.
“Thy days are known and they shall not be counted less.”
But what did the Lord bless him with? His greatest, most genuine, and sincerely desire!
There was nothing that Arthur wanted more than that which he got, a reuniting and a redemption of his relationship with his band mates, and another moment on stage – not to consume it upon his lusts, but to enjoy it for its pleasure.
But the lesson here is in combination with what the Lord got out of it.
Did Arthur convert a soul while he was on stage? Probably not.
Did the church and kingdom of God expand its stakes as a result? Most of us would doubt it.
For all known intents and purposes there was no other purpose in this blessing than to bring joy and happiness to a faithful son of God. The Lord did this for Arthur, and for no other person, and for no other intent.
Not to minimize the Lords intent, power, or ability, but it is difficult to identify eternal courses as a result of rock concerts, unless you look into the heart of the aged bass player on stage and witness the joy in his heart as a result of his deepest desire being fulfilled.
Our Father is a father of individuals and children. “If a child ask for a fish, will his father give him a serpent?” He loves us with genuine care and compassion. He cares for us, and desires us to find joy in this life and in eternal life to come. There are times when his actions are for no other purpose but our temporal happiness – as those times also exist with our temporal parents.
The example of Arthur Kane, is an example of how much the Lord knows and is aware of each of his children, their wants, their desires, their abilities, and the course of their live. It is an example of what he will do for us as we seek him with sincere faith, and loving obedience. And as with any parent, it is an example of the great joy he feels when he is able to provide joyful opportunities to his faithful children. The story of Arthur is a story of the love of a Father for a son.